.
.

What Makes You & Doesn’t Make You a ‘Creonte’ in BJJ

[post-views]
What Makes You & Doesn’t Make You a ‘Creonte’ in BJJ

The term creonte originated within Brazilian jiu-jitsu organizations in Brazil to refer to a student who either is, or perceived to be, disloyal to a particular school or organization, particularly one with which the student had a long-standing or otherwise well-invested relationship. As such, the expression is used pejoratively, and has drawn comparisons to the English word traitor.

The coining of the term is credited to the late grandmaster Carlson Gracie who is said to have adopted the name from a character in a popular TV Soap opera broadcast in Brazil. The character had many allegiances and changed his mind and loyalties frequently.

But who really qualifies as a “Creonte”?

Ben Boyce of Carlson Gracie New Zealand wrote to BJJEE:

“There has been a lot of talk regarding the term “Creonte” lately, and as such I would like to address the misconception that seems to have occurred within the Jiu-Jitsu community.

This misconception has been largely made worse by some well reputable practitioners of Jiu-Jitsu weighing in, yet missing the key point.

Jason Scully: BJJ “Family” and “Loyalty” is Utter BS

Without going into the well known and easily available history of the term “Creonte”, I wanted to address it’s core principle.

Creonte” is a concept. It is not a label simply applied to one who changes teams or moves cities or areas, and it certainly doesn’t apply to people who occasionally train at other gyms. This interpretation, or misinterpretation, of the term seems to be a very common misconception that has developed recently.

A “Creonte” is one who commits a betrayal (and it is a betrayal) on a deeper level, not just in regards to their Jiu-Jitsu “team”, but in regards to the people who put great effort and investment into helping them become the competitor, athlete and/or fighter they are.

What To Do When A New Black Belt Wants to Leave & Start Their Own Team

Take a generic example; a gym/instructor invests heavily in a young talented athlete for many years; teaching, promoting them as an athlete by finding fights, organising seminars, sponsoring them financially; training and helping at a personal and financial level. This athlete eventually achieves great success propelled by his/her talent, dedication, and drive but also propped up by years of assistance and coaching. The now successful athlete is then presented with a “better offer (financially)” from another gym/team. They make the switch (as it is on the face of it a better financial offer), suddenly forgetting those who helped them to be in the position they are in to even get this offer.
That is a “Creonte”.

The fact of the matter is, most people that are commenting that “I pay for classes, I can go wherever I want”, well they are right. This does not make you a “Creonte”, it perhaps makes you a smart consumer.
However at the same time these same people will likely never have the opportunity to even be in a position where anyone would seriously call them a “Creonte”.

Instructor Offers To Pay For His Students To Train At Other Gyms

So stop talking about your monthly gym membership, and your right to take your business wherever you want, no one is arguing that.

 

Also read:

‘Creontism’: Jiu-Jitsu’s Biggest Hypocrisy