Why is Aikido Disliked by BJJ and MMA Practitioners?

Why is Aikido Disliked by BJJ and MMA Practitioners?

Aikido, once a renowned and respected martial art, has seen a significant decline in popularity in recent years. It has come under criticism, especially from practitioners of modern martial arts such as Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu and Mixed Martial Arts. This shift in perception raises questions about why Aikido has fallen out of favor and what can be done to revive its standing in the martial arts community.

The Roots of Aikido

Aikido was developed in the early 20th century by Morihei Ueshiba, who sought to create a martial art that emphasized harmony and the redirection of an opponent’s energy. Unlike many other martial arts, Aikido focuses on using an opponent’s force against them rather than relying on brute strength or aggression. This philosophy attracted many practitioners seeking a disciplined, non-violent form of self-defense.

Criticisms from BJJ and MMA Practitioners

1.Lack of Realistic Training: One of the primary criticisms from BJJ and MMA practitioners is that Aikido often lacks realistic training scenarios. While BJJ and MMA emphasize live sparring and competition, where techniques are tested under pressure, Aikido training typically involves pre-arranged forms (katas) and cooperative drills. This approach is seen as less effective in preparing practitioners for real-world self-defense situations.

2.Ineffectiveness in Combat Sports: Aikido techniques are rarely seen in competitive combat sports. In contrast, BJJ and MMA have proven their effectiveness in numerous competitions worldwide. The absence of Aikido techniques in these arenas leads many to question their practicality and relevance in actual combat situations.

3.Philosophical Differences: The philosophy of Aikido, which emphasizes harmony and non-resistance, often contrasts sharply with the more combative and competitive nature of BJJ and MMA. Practitioners of these modern martial arts may view Aikido’s principles as outdated or unrealistic in the context of modern self-defense and sport fighting.

Aikido’s Struggle for Relevance

Aikido’s decline can also be attributed to its struggle to adapt to modern expectations of martial arts training. In an era where effectiveness and practicality are highly valued, Aikido’s traditional and philosophical approach can seem out of touch.

What Can Save Aikido?

Despite the criticisms, there are ways Aikido can regain its relevance and respect within the martial arts community:

1.Incorporate Live Sparring: Introducing more live sparring and resistance-based training can help Aikido practitioners test their techniques in realistic scenarios. This approach would bridge the gap between traditional Aikido and the demands of modern self-defense.

2.Cross-Training: Encouraging Aikido practitioners to cross-train in other martial arts, such as BJJ or MMA, can enhance their understanding of different fighting styles and improve their adaptability. Cross-training can also demonstrate the complementary aspects of Aikido techniques when combined with other disciplines.

3.Highlight Practical Applications: Aikido instructors can focus on the practical applications of techniques in real-world scenarios. Demonstrating how Aikido can be effective in self-defense situations can help dispel myths about its ineffectiveness.

4.Promote Aikido’s Unique Benefits: Aikido offers unique benefits such as improved balance, coordination, and mental discipline. Emphasizing these aspects can attract practitioners who value personal development and inner peace as much as physical prowess.

5.Engage with the Martial Arts Community: Building bridges with the wider martial arts community through seminars, workshops, and open training sessions can foster mutual respect and understanding. Engaging with practitioners of other martial arts can help dispel misconceptions and showcase Aikido’s strengths.

Aikido’s decline in popularity, particularly among BJJ and MMA practitioners, stems from perceptions of its lack of realism and effectiveness in combat. However, by adapting training methods, encouraging cross-training, and highlighting its unique benefits, Aikido can reclaim its place as a respected and valuable martial art. The path to revitalization lies in bridging the gap between tradition and modernity, demonstrating that Aikido’s principles remain relevant in today’s martial arts landscape.

Unlock the power of a unique and highly effective BJJ technique with “The Game Over Position” video instructional. Developed by Guillaume “Gile” Huni, a 3rd-degree BJJ black belt with over 23 years of Jiu-Jitsu experience, this course unveils a top-side control crucifix position that he has refined through decades of practice and competition.