Marcelo Garcia, one of the most revered figures in grappling history, recently shared his perspective on Gordon Ryan’s dominance and the ongoing debate about who deserves the title of the greatest no-gi grappler of all time. Speaking with MMA Fighting, Garcia provided a nuanced take on Ryan’s achievements while highlighting key considerations in the GOAT discussion.
When asked if Ryan has earned the title of GOAT, Garcia was cautious but acknowledged Ryan’s exceptional status.
“He’s at the top right now, but it’s hard to say he’s the greatest of all time,” Garcia remarked.
Reflecting on his own career, Garcia noted the unique challenges he faced as a 170-pound competitor taking on opponents much larger than him, particularly during a time when steroid use was rampant.
“I don’t want to be a hypocrite here. I know I’ve done a lot. I’ve done a lot being the size I am, 170 pounds, and facing the best in my weight class and the absolute, guys that were bigger than me, and imagining that many people were using steroids,” he said.
While Garcia acknowledges Ryan’s incredible talent and potential to eventually claim the GOAT title, he emphasized that the issue of performance-enhancing drug (PED) use is a significant factor in the discussion.
“If he continues to compete and no one beats him, and continues to have the performances he’s putting on, you can’t say [he’s not the GOAT], and he’s young too. Of course, he can be that guy,” Garcia stated. “But I can say all I’ve done was steroid-free. I don’t know that’s the case with Gordon. To me, that’s a decisive point, if someone needed extra help or not.”
Garcia also pointed to the fundamental principle of achieving success through personal effort and skill, underscoring that his own accomplishments came solely from training and technique.
“Like people say: ‘That person didn’t come alone.’ I was alone every single time, only with my training and my technique,” he explained. “And when people say: ‘Oh, but everybody uses it.’ Not to me. That excuse doesn’t make sense to me.”
This perspective adds a layer of complexity to the GOAT debate, as it raises questions about the role of PEDs in competitive grappling and whether they undermine an athlete’s legacy. Ryan, widely regarded as the most dominant no-gi grappler of his generation, has achieved unparalleled success, particularly in the ADCC, which is considered the pinnacle of the sport. However, the long-term implications of PED use and its impact on the GOAT conversation remain a polarizing topic.
For now, Marcelo Garcia acknowledges Ryan’s greatness but stops short of crowning him as the GOAT. As Ryan continues to compete and push the boundaries of the sport, the debate over his legacy—and what truly defines the greatest of all time—will undoubtedly persist.
Sloth Jiu-Jitsu: you can be slow and unathletic and still kick butt in Jiu-Jitsu.
